Calendar › Pending home sales › 2026-11-18
Pending Home Sales -4.7% vs -2.0% Est — Second Straight Record Low, -16.7% on the Year
Fundamentals · 2026-11-18
Pending home sales -4.7% m/m in October vs -2.0% consensus (TradingEconomics), after -7.3% in September (first reported); -16.7% y/y, from -11.3% in September and -4.7% in August; "two consecutive months of record-low pending contracts" (Yun); declines in all four regions on both measures: West -6.9% m/m, -20.3% y/y; South -6.3%, -18.7%; Midwest -2.7%, -14.0%; Northeast -0.8%, -11.1%; the best of the 50 largest metros was Cincinnati at -4.7% y/y, the tenth-best -12.8%; 30-year mortgage averaged 7.33% in October (Freddie Mac), peaking at 7.40%, and has eased to 7.11% (12 November); Yun: October "could mark the low point in contract signings for this housing cycle." Next release 17 December.
What It Changes
- Contracts fell again from a record low. A 4.7% drop against a 2.0% expected dip is a miss of 2.7 percentage points, and NAR's chief economist calls September and October two consecutive record lows for the series, which starts in 2001.
- The annual decline keeps widening. -4.7% in August, -11.3% in September, -16.7% in October. Contracts signed now close in November and December, so fourth-quarter existing-home sales have further to fall from October's 3.75 million rate, already the slowest since 2010.
- NAR is calling the bottom, and the rate data gives it a reason. Freddie Mac's 30-year rate peaked at 7.40% in mid-October and has fallen 29bp since, to 7.11%. October's contracts were signed at the peak.
- For the Fed, this is the rate channel working, not a reason to stop. With the funds rate at 3.75-4.00% (Fed) and the 10-year at 5.10% (US Treasury, 17 November), housing is where tight policy lands first. It does not change December hike pricing on its own.
Impact
- USD — Neutral to slight bearish — another housing miss takes a little from the case for more than one more hike, but pending sales rarely moves the dollar, and the FOMC minutes at 14:00 are the day's rate input.
- The release came at 10:00, after the cash open, on a session trading Nvidia and the rate path.
- US Indices (ES / NQ / YM / RTY) — Slight bearish for RTY — mortgage lenders, regional banks, homebuilders and building-products names sit disproportionately in small caps, and fewer contracts mean fewer closings and fewer mortgages ahead.
- ES, NQ and YM have little direct exposure to existing-home volumes.
- Gold (GC) — Neutral — no direct path from a housing-contracts print to gold, which is trading the dollar and real yields.
Inside The Number
Pending home sales fell 4.7% in October from September, and 16.7% from October 2025, according to the National Association of Realtors. Consensus was -2.0% (TradingEconomics; The Open carried the same), so this is a miss of 2.7 percentage points. September's -7.3% was the prior as first reported.
The level is the headline, and NAR said it plainly. NAR no longer publishes the index level in its release, but Chief Economist Lawrence Yun did the comparison for us: "Two consecutive months of record-low pending contracts point to very sluggish fourth-quarter home sales closings, and annual existing-home sales could be the lowest since the mid-1990s." The index began in 2001, so September and October are the two lowest months of contract signings in its history, below anything in the 2008-2011 housing bust or the 2020 lockdown.
The breadth is complete for a second month. All four regions fell on the month and on the year. The West fell most, -6.9% m/m and -20.3% y/y, followed by the South (-6.3%, -18.7%), the Midwest (-2.7%, -14.0%) and the Northeast (-0.8%, -11.1%). The monthly falls were smaller than September's in every region, but each came on top of September's drop, so every region's annual decline widened.
The metro list moved down again. NAR lists the ten of the 50 largest metros with the smallest annual declines, using Realtor.com data. Every one is negative for a second month, and the whole list has shifted lower. The best was Cincinnati at -4.7%; the tenth, Cleveland, was -12.8%. A month ago the best was Nashville at -2.0% and the tenth -7.1%. So 40 of the 50 largest metros saw contracts fall by 12.8% or more on the year.
Contracts are still running ahead of closings on the way down. Existing-home sales fell to a 3.75 million rate in October, -8.8% on the year (NAR, 12 November). Contracts are down 16.7%. The gap between them is 7.9 points, against 9.1 a month ago, so closings are catching down toward contracts rather than contracts recovering. Since a contract usually closes within one or two months, October's signings are a read on November and December closings.
Yun's call is that the rate peak is behind us. "October could mark the low point in contract signings for this housing cycle, as mortgage rates appear to have topped out," he said. The Freddie Mac series supports the second half of that: the 30-year rate reached 7.40% on 8 and 15 October, the highest weekly reading since November 2023, and has eased every week since, to 7.11% on 12 November. He also framed the puzzle: sales at levels "last seen three decades ago, even as the U.S. population has grown by roughly 75 million," which means "either sizable housing demand is building in the background, or the dream of homeownership is increasingly out of reach."
The narrative point: the 20 October brief said a further decline in October was likely with the 30-year rate at 7.28-7.40% through the first half of the month, and that closings would fall toward the pace of contracts. Both happened. This morning's housing starts showed single-family permits at their lowest since January 2023, and yesterday's NAHB index hit its lowest since April 2012. The resale market, the builders and the permits all point the same way.
The Internals
Measure · October · September · Change in pace · Read
National, m/m · -4.7% · -7.3% · 2.6 points smaller fall · Miss of 2.7 points vs -2.0% est
National, y/y · -16.7% · -11.3% · 5.4 points weaker · Third month of widening
Existing-home sales, y/y · -8.8% · -2.2% · 6.6 points weaker · Closings catching down
Contracts minus closings, y/y · -7.9 points · -9.1 points · Gap narrowed · Closings falling toward contracts
Index level · Record low · Record low · Second straight · Per NAR's Yun; series from 2001
The annual change in contracts, month by month:
Month · Pending sales y/y · Pending sales m/m
August 2026 · -4.7% · +0.3%
September 2026 · -11.3% · -7.3%
October 2026 · -16.7% · -4.7%
Mortgage rates through the signing window, Freddie Mac weekly 30-year fixed:
Week of · Rate · Change
24 September 2026 · 7.03% · n/a
1 October 2026 · 7.28% · +25bp
8 October 2026 · 7.40% · +12bp
15 October 2026 · 7.40% · 0bp
22 October 2026 · 7.32% · -8bp
29 October 2026 · 7.24% · -8bp
5 November 2026 · 7.18% · -6bp
12 November 2026 · 7.11% · -7bp
- October averaged 7.33%, against 6.86% in September and 6.25% in October 2025, a year-on-year rise of 108bp.
- The peak was in the middle of the signing month. Rates have fallen four weeks running since, a total of 29bp, which is the basis for Yun's "topped out."
Regional And Metro Detail
Region · October m/m · September m/m · October y/y · September y/y · Read
West · -6.9% · -9.2% · -20.3% · -15.0% · Largest decline on both measures again
South · -6.3% · -8.2% · -18.7% · -12.0% · Largest widening on the year
Midwest · -2.7% · -6.5% · -14.0% · -8.7% · Fall less than half September's
Northeast · -0.8% · -4.2% · -11.1% · -9.4% · Nearly flat on the month
The ten of the 50 largest metros with the smallest annual declines (NAR, using Realtor.com Economics data):
Rank · Metro · y/y
1 · Cincinnati, OH · -4.7%
2 · Austin, TX · -9.7%
3 · Hartford, CT · -10.0%
4 · Indianapolis, IN · -11.3%
5 · Chicago, IL · -11.9%
6 · Pittsburgh, PA · -12.4%
7 · Nashville, TN · -12.7%
8 · Buffalo, NY · -12.7%
9 · Jacksonville, FL · -12.8%
10 · Cleveland, OH · -12.8%
- These are the best ten, not the worst. The other forty of the largest metros fell by 12.8% or more on the year.
- Nashville went from first to seventh. It led last month at -2.0% and is now -12.7%. Austin, Hartford, Pittsburgh and Buffalo also repeat, each with a deeper decline.
- The list leans Midwest, with Cincinnati, Indianapolis, Chicago and Cleveland, which fits the Midwest's smaller regional fall. No Western metro made the ten.
Against This Morning's Open
- The Open listed pending home sales at 10:00 with a -2.0% consensus and a -7.3% prior, tagged to RTY, and said housing starts and pending home sales were "unlikely to move December pricing on their own; they matter for RTY, where homebuilders and regional banks sit."
- The print missed at -4.7%, and both of the morning's housing releases pointed lower on the forward-looking measure: permits at 08:30, contracts at 10:00. The RTY framing holds; nothing here reaches December pricing.
What This Sets Up
- Next release: Thursday 17 December, for November.
- Confirms Yun's bottom call: a monthly rise in November contracts, signed with the 30-year rate below 7.2% in each November week so far, and a narrower annual decline than October's 16.7%.
- Breaks it: a third straight record low, which would mean lower rates have not yet brought buyers back.
- Watch the gap against closings. It narrowed to 7.9 points from 9.1 as closings fell faster. If November existing-home sales (9 December) fall toward -15% on the year, the two series have converged at the bottom.
What Is This?
- What it is: The Pending Home Sales report from the National Association of Realtors, measuring signed contracts on existing single-family homes, condos and co-ops. A sale counts as pending when the contract is signed but the sale has not closed; most close within one or two months. The index is based on a sample covering about 40% of multiple listing service data each month, with an index of 100 equal to the average contract activity in 2001. NAR now publishes the release as monthly and yearly % changes, nationally and for four regions, plus a list of metro areas drawn from Realtor.com data.
- Why it matters: It is the earliest read on existing-home sales, which are the large majority of US home purchases. With mortgage rates at their highest since 2023 and the Fed priced for another hike, it shows how quickly higher rates are reaching home buyers, and whether the recent dip in rates is bringing them back.
- How to read it: Contracts lead closings by one to two months, so a decline today shows up in existing-home sales next month and the month after. The monthly change is volatile; the yearly change and the gap against existing-home sales are steadier guides. NAR does not publish an index level in the release, so compare changes rather than levels.
Want the full explainer? Economic News Events, Explained breaks down this release and every other one we cover, in plain English.
_For informational purposes only. Not investment advice._